Email Marketing

Email sender reputation 101: a comprehensive guide

A high sender reputation is essential for successful delivery into the inbox and engagement when it comes to email marketing. Understanding email sender reputation and its importance is critical for any business or individual sending emails. Let’s delve into the intricacies of email sender reputation, and we’ll provide valuable insights on how to build and maintain a strong reputation.

Understanding email sender reputation

Email sender reputation refers to the reputation or trustworthiness of the sender’s email domain and associated sending IPs. It is a measure used by internet service providers (ISPs) to assess the quality and potential impact of each email sent. A sender with a good reputation is much more likely to have their emails delivered to the recipients’ inboxes, while a poor reputation can result in emails being flagged as spam or blocked altogether.

Having a good email sender reputation is not just about ensuring that your emails are delivered, but also about building trust and credibility with your recipients. It shows that you are a legitimate sender who wants to build a relationship by following best practices while respecting the preferences of your subscribers.

When it comes to email sender reputation, it’s important to understand that it is not a static measure. It can change over time based on various factors, including your sending practices, recipient engagement, and feedback from ISPs and ESPs.

Importance of email sender reputation

A good email sender reputation is crucial for maintaining high deliverability rates and ensuring that your messages reach the intended recipients. It helps build trust with ISPs, who are responsible for filtering out spam and protecting users’ inboxes. When your reputation is strong, ISPs are more likely to prioritize your emails, increasing the chances of them landing in the primary inbox rather than the spam folder.

On the other hand, a poor reputation can have serious consequences for your email marketing efforts. It can lead to decreased deliverability rates, meaning that a significant portion of your emails may never reach your subscribers. This can result in reduced engagement, lower open and click-through rates, and ultimately, a negative impact on your marketing ROI.

Furthermore, a bad sender reputation can also damage your brand’s credibility. If your emails consistently end up in the spam folder or are blocked altogether, it can create a negative perception of your brand among recipients. They may view your emails as untrustworthy or irrelevant, leading to unsubscribes and a loss of potential customers.

Factors influencing email sender reputation

Several factors contribute to your email sender reputation. Here are some key considerations:

  1. Email authentication: Implementing proper authentication protocols, such as SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance), helps verify that the emails you send are legitimate and not forged. These protocols add an extra layer of security and trustworthiness to your emails.
  2. IP address reputation: The reputation of the IP address from which you send emails plays a significant role. An IP address with a history of spamming or suspicious activity can adversely affect your reputation. It is important to ensure that your IP address has a clean history and is not associated with any malicious or spammy behavior.
  3. Subscriber complaints: High volumes of spam complaints indicate that recipients are not interested in your emails or perceive them as unsolicited. It is crucial to promptly address any complaints and unsubscribe requests. Regularly reviewing your email list and removing inactive or disengaged subscribers can also help reduce the likelihood of complaints.
  4. Email engagement: The level of engagement your emails receive also impacts your sender reputation. ISPs and ESPs monitor metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and spam complaints to gauge the quality and relevance of your emails. Emails that consistently generate positive engagement signals, such as high open and click-through rates, are more likely to have a positive impact on your reputation.
  5. Email volume and frequency: The volume and frequency at which you send emails can have an impact. Sending a high volume of emails in a short period or sending emails too frequently can raise red flags and trigger spam filters. It’s important to find the right balance and adhere to industry best practices when it comes to email frequency.
  6. Dedicated vs shared IPs:
    Having dedicated IPs allows the sender to have full control over their reputation. The fact your IP reputation won’t be affected by other users will enhance your security, and ultimately result in increased deliverability rates.
    There’s good news and bad news when using shared IPs. The good news is you can piggyback off the reputation of good senders. The bad news is you can piggyback off the reputation of bad senders as well. A shared IP allows you to avoid the work of warming up your IP and allows you to utilize the more seasoned reputation of a shared IP. This route is ideal for smaller or newer senders.

Blocklisting and sender reputation

One of the most severe consequences of a poor sender reputation is the risk of being blocklisted by ISPs or anti-spam organizations. When your domain or IP address is blocklisted, it means that your emails are flagged as spam or potentially harmful, and as a result, they may be blocked entirely or routed to recipients’ spam folders, regardless of their actual content.

Getting removed from blocklists can be a challenging and time-consuming process, often requiring you to identify and rectify the underlying issues that caused the blocklisting in the first place. This can involve investigating and resolving any security vulnerabilities, addressing spam complaints, and implementing robust email authentication protocols.

Being blocklisted not only affects your ability to communicate effectively via email but also damages your brand reputation and trust among your subscribers. It is essential to proactively monitor your sender reputation and take necessary measures to maintain a positive reputation, ensuring the deliverability and effectiveness of your email marketing efforts.

Building a strong email reputation

Quality of email content
Creating compelling and relevant email content is essential for maintaining a good sender reputation. Avoid using excessive promotional language or deceptive subject lines. Instead, focus on providing value to your subscribers through informative and engaging content that matches their expectations.

Regularity and consistency of emails
Consistently sending emails at regular intervals establishes trust with your subscribers, as it demonstrates your commitment and reliability. However, ensure that you don’t overwhelm your audience with excessive frequency, as it can lead to increased unsubscribe rates and negatively impact your reputation.

Subscriber list management
Proper email list hygiene is crucial for maintaining a healthy sender reputation. Regularly clean your subscriber list by removing invalid or inactive email addresses and promptly honoring unsubscribe requests. Engage in permission-based marketing practices, ensuring that you have explicit consent to send emails to recipients.

Monitoring your email sender reputation

Tools for monitoring sender reputation
Several tools and services are available to monitor your email sender reputation, such as Outlook SNDS and Google’s Postmaster Tools. These tools provide valuable insights into your deliverability rates, spam complaints, and reputation scores, allowing you to identify and address any issues promptly.

Interpreting reputation scores
Reputation scores assigned by various monitoring services can provide an indication of your sender reputation. These scores are based on factors such as email volume, engagement rates, and spam complaints. It’s important to regularly review and interpret these scores to understand how your reputation may be perceived by ISPs and ESPs.

Regular check-ups and adjustments
Maintaining a good email sender reputation requires ongoing monitoring and adjustments. Regularly review your deliverability metrics, engagement rates, and feedback loops to identify any potential issues. Address any concerns promptly and adapt your email marketing strategies based on the feedback and insights gained from monitoring your reputation.

Prefer the experts to monitor this for you?
We’re here to help! At Inboxable, we offer a range of metrics and indicators that track important factors such as inboxing rates, IP/domain reputation, blocklistings, and spam complaints. Our team of deliverability experts will not only monitor your campaigns but also provide recommendations and proactively troubleshoot any issues we identify on your behalf.

Get in touch

Stephen Taunt
Stephen Taunt
Senior Deliverability Analyst

Stephen Taunt is a Senior Deliverability Analyst on the Inboxable team at Data Axle. With over a decade of data and client relations experience under his belt, he has worked within multiple industries ranging from the music business to global aviation media. Stephen’s passion for all things deliverability help drive his clients' success, leveraging data-driven and strategic tactics.